Teenager used steak knives for Portsmouth stabbing

The scales of justice

Here’s the latest on who’s been in court

0
Have your say

THIS is a knife used by a teenager who tried to murder lone women in three stabbing attacks in Portsmouth last summer.

Ben Moynihan was found guilty of three counts of attempted murder following a six-day trial.

op bedham knife re cosham and hilsea stabbings''Katie BARRY'A/DS 24303'Hampshire Major Investigation Team'Dances Lane; Whitchurch; Hampshire, RG28 7EG'Int 624230; DD; 01256406418; Mobile 07717347554''15 x prints of each highlighted for trial MJE 18/12/14

op bedham knife re cosham and hilsea stabbings''Katie BARRY'A/DS 24303'Hampshire Major Investigation Team'Dances Lane; Whitchurch; Hampshire, RG28 7EG'Int 624230; DD; 01256406418; Mobile 07717347554''15 x prints of each highlighted for trial MJE 18/12/14

Winchester Crown Court heard the women, aged 20, 45 and 67, each suffered a single wound to their breast area in the attacks.

A different but identical steak knife with a 4.5in blade was used in the first attack.

The first victim suffered a 2cm wound and the second woman also had a 2cm wound. The third woman received a 1.5cm wound.

DNA from the second and third victim was found on the knife, which he had taken from a kitchen drawer at his home.

op bedham knife re cosham and hilsea stabbings''Katie BARRY'A/DS 24303'Hampshire Major Investigation Team'Dances Lane; Whitchurch; Hampshire, RG28 7EG'Int 624230; DD; 01256406418; Mobile 07717347554''15 x prints of each highlighted for trial MJE 18/12/14 PPP-150120-095956001

op bedham knife re cosham and hilsea stabbings''Katie BARRY'A/DS 24303'Hampshire Major Investigation Team'Dances Lane; Whitchurch; Hampshire, RG28 7EG'Int 624230; DD; 01256406418; Mobile 07717347554''15 x prints of each highlighted for trial MJE 18/12/14 PPP-150120-095956001

In the witness box Moynihan acted out how he stabbed each of the women, using his right arm to swing the knife.

He told police he struck when they were in his ‘sweet spot.’

Prosecutor Kerry Maylin said: ‘He knew all he needed was a knife. He didn’t stab them in exactly the same way. He chose women of differing ages, different clothes and a different motion to stab them.’

Stabber left letters mocking the police

stabber cosham and hilsea Ben Moynihan and NOTE''Ben Moynihan, who is up for stabbing the three women.''From: Ben Fishwick <Ben.fishwick@thenews.co.uk> PPP-150115-165759001

stabber cosham and hilsea Ben Moynihan and NOTE''Ben Moynihan, who is up for stabbing the three women.''From: Ben Fishwick <Ben.fishwick@thenews.co.uk> PPP-150115-165759001

TWO letters were left for police after the teenager struck.

Moynihan left the first, with a symbol from the game Tomb Radier, in an alleyway where the third victim was stabbed.

It was found by a couple who handed it in to police.

It said: ‘I am not a psychopath; I am “the unhappy geezer”. When women won’t talk to you, it’s heart breaking. Why are they fussy with men now days? When jobs turn you down, it’s emotional to think how fussy they are.

stabber cosham and hilsea Ben Moynihan and NOTE''Ben Moynihan, who is up for stabbing the three women.''From: Ben Fishwick <Ben.fishwick@thenews.co.uk>

stabber cosham and hilsea Ben Moynihan and NOTE''Ben Moynihan, who is up for stabbing the three women.''From: Ben Fishwick <Ben.fishwick@thenews.co.uk>

‘Even part time hours.

‘In fact, this unhappy geezer has a hard time making friends and is often lonely.

‘I tried to be good but I am always bullied for being unintelligent. The Unhappy Geezer needs dignity; maybe it is best if I rot in Broadmoor, Ramptom [sic], or Ashworth. But when that happens can I request to bring my laptop with me, not for internet, just something to do.

‘Until then I bid you a good day with the happy lives you have, cause I roam these streets hungry for blood and pain. I be greeted as attack, attack, attack, attack, attack, dead, jolly good! Yours faithfully Unhappy Geezer.’

The first letter was written in April at South Downs College, where Moynihan was studying catering. The second letter was put on a police van on July 12. A section of it said: ‘All women needs to die.

‘I’m now going to show you a picture of myself and see how good you guys and be, come and arrest me for god sake before I hunt for my 4th victim. CATCH ME IF YOU CAN!’

STABBING COSHAM   (RS & CF)     MRW   11/7/2014  ''Scene of Crime Officers together with detectives and uniformed Police Officers at the scene of a crime in a pathway that goes between Northern Road in Cosham and Colwell Road Cosham 'Detectives made house-to-house enquiries as other officers checked bins, drains and garden areas ''Picture: Malcolm Wells (142041-0561) PPP-141107-221739003

STABBING COSHAM (RS & CF) MRW 11/7/2014 ''Scene of Crime Officers together with detectives and uniformed Police Officers at the scene of a crime in a pathway that goes between Northern Road in Cosham and Colwell Road Cosham 'Detectives made house-to-house enquiries as other officers checked bins, drains and garden areas ''Picture: Malcolm Wells (142041-0561) PPP-141107-221739003

‘Diary of evil’ kept on laptop listed attacks

FORENSIC officers found Ben Moynihan’s ‘diary of evil’ he kept on his laptop.

Prosecutor Kerry Maylin said Moynihan kept his diary separate from a file called ‘my crazy dreams’.

Rachel Fraser, from Hampshire police, read the opening paragraph and said: ‘I was planning to murder mainly women as an act of revenge because of the life they gave me.

‘I’m still a virgin at 17 and why do women have to be fussy when choosing a boyfriend.

‘I attack women because women I grew up to believe them as a more weaker part of the human breed.

‘I also done it to get out this horrible life.

‘I’m not a bad child and didn’t want to do this but had no choice.’

Another entry on June 15 said he witnessed two men burgle his family garage.

It said: ‘That traumatised me. I’m angry at all society from now on.’

Another entry written under June 20, the day of the first stabbing, said: ‘I done the baddest thing I ever done. I saw a girl around my age walking in front of me.

‘I stabbed her in the left breast. She made a little grunt. I went “ha ha” and ran away. That night I did carry a bit of guilt on me.

‘By now I’ve lost my guilt and regained my anger.’

A later entry added: ‘My actions are now on the front page. I love all the attention.’

The file was created on June 16 last year and most recently altered on July 12.

Troubled teenager recorded chilling video

WAVING a knife at a digital camera and talking about killing women, Ben Moynihan recorded a chilling message found by police.

He said: ‘Ben Moynihan here, also known as the unhappy geezer.

‘It’s your fault. All you people make me sick, do you know why? Because I’ve done nothing wrong. I’m only a bit slower and stupid than anyone else.

‘That gives you no right to bully me whatsoever. Five years I’ve been bullied at my secondary school.

‘I’ve only had two friends out the whole lot of you and I lost them.

‘I thought I was more mature than you all put together.’

He added: ‘There’s no work any more. And Portsmouth, for two years I’ve been trying to get out of Portsmouth.’

He then added: ‘I’m to be cremated and scattered around the IBM building in North Harbour around the fields.

‘That’s my request because it’s my favourite place in the whole world.’

On women Moynihan said: ‘I think every girl is a total slut.

‘I’m still a virgin, everyone is losing it before me, which is why you’re my chosen target. I love my family, every single member. It’s just I can’t live in this flat. I’ve got no future here.’

Waving a knife at the camera and then holding a lit cigarette lighter, he adds: ‘Shall I stab you in the neck or in the heart, shall I slash your throat or should I just cigarette lighter you or just fire you.’

‘I don’t know where I could get petrol from but how hard can it be to come by?

‘So I hope you learn a lesson not to blame guys like this who deserve dignity. Remember that for your own generations. Remember that.’

The teenager recorded the message on June 13 before transferring it to his laptop on June 15.

Police satisfied with verdict

Acting Detective Sergeant Katie Barry said police linked Moynihan’s attacks after the second stabbing.

Det Sgt Barry, pictured, said police were very satisfied with the verdict.

She said: ‘Over that particular weekend, that’s when a lot of resources from Hampshire, from community safety as well, went into catching the person responsible.

‘We didn’t know the state of mind of that person.’

Simon Casey, the detective sergeant running the investigation before he retired, praised the officers who spotted Moynihan and arrested him.

Coverage of the trial

Portsmouth stabbings trial: Teenager found guilty of attempted murder

Portsmouth stabbings trial: Teenager’s claim he wanted to kill women was ‘just a fantasy’

Portsmouth stabbings trial: Defendant tells court he lied to police

Accused Portsmouth teenager ‘stabbed women to death in a video game’

Solidarity walk in Portsmouth after stabbing inspired teenager accused of attempted murder

‘Those three were not the only times I took out a knife - I had it out ready’

Teenager stabbed women because he ‘felt worthless’

Portsmouth attacks trial hears defendant told police: ‘Yeah, I confess to the stabbings.’

‘I looked down and there was blood... he had stabbed me’

Portsmouth stab victims tell court of attacks in attempted murder trial

Stabbing accused said he looked for ‘blood and pain’

Court told teenager stabbed women ‘because he could not lose his virginity’