Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 1st August 2010

Portsmouth Tesco refuse to sell alcohol to 46-year-old mum

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
03 March 2009
A mum was told she couldn't buy wine at a supermarket in case she gave it to her 14-year-old daughter.
Karen Dumelow queued up with her weekly shopping, including two bottles of Tesco Finest white wine.

But the checkout worker refused to serve the 46-year-old, saying she needed to see identification for daughter Emily.

Mrs Dumelow then approached three senior members of staff at the North Harbour store, but they backed their colleague.

'I was a bit bemused and said "my daughter doesn't have ID – she's only 14 years old!",' said Mrs Dumelow, a fraud investigator.

'My daughter was with me because I take her shopping.

'I don't leave her home alone. I was paying for the shopping, not her, how extreme can something get?'

Mrs Dumelow, from Shelford Road, Milton, was forced to put aside the two bottles of wine and pay for the rest of the shopping.

She then had to send off her daughter to the car so she could put the bottles of wine through the same till.

'My till receipts support this madness, I have one recorded at 5.28pm purchasing groceries and the second recorded at 5.29pm for two bottles of wine.

'I would never purchase alcohol for an under-age person. I'm sure now there are many Tesco customers who do not believe that to be the case as this incident took place in the middle of a busy store and clearly did not go unnoticed, so what does that make me look like?

'I'm a professional person, I always abide by the law and find it extremely distressing to have been treated and embarrassed in this way.'

Daughter Emily added: 'It was embarrassing. I don't understand why they wanted ID for me because it wasn't for me and I wasn't paying.

'I don't have ID but if I did it would have shown I was 14 so it was stupid.'

Tesco has now apologised for the incident.

Spokesman David Nieberg said: 'We're sorry for the inconvenience and any embarrassment we have caused this customer.

'We work hard to prevent under-age sales, including proxy sales where adults purchase alcohol for under-18s.

'However in this instance we got it wrong and sincerely apologise.'


WHAT OTHER SUPERMARKETS SAY

Sainsbury's – spokeswoman Cheryl Kuczynski said: 'The vast majority of our customers who buy alcohol do so as part of their regular and large grocery shop and we do, of course, sell alcohol to shoppers accompanied by children.
'However, it is against the law for an adult to buy alcohol for a child or young person under the age of 18. If a colleague believes that an adult is buying alcohol for an under age person to consume, we err on the side of caution and refuse to sell alcohol to that person.'

Waitrose – spokeswoman Jess Hughes said: 'Our checkout staff are trained to "Think 21" when serving alcohol.
'If there is reason to believe that the customer is buying the alcoholic drink for someone under age then the sale would be refused.'

Asda – spokeswoman Sian Horner said: 'If someone doesn't look 25 they are challenged for ID.
'We judge every case independently. Every colleague is held accountable by law if they sell alcohol to an under-age person.
'If in doubt, challenge for ID, that's the rule we stick to.'

Morrisons – spokeswoman Melanie Hill said: 'We have a TASK 25 Scheme which ensures that if we believe a customer wishing to purchase alcohol is under the age of 25, they will be asked to provide recognised proof of age documentation.
'Under current licensing laws, stores are not allowed to sell an alcoholic product to a customer who is suspected of buying for a minor or for someone who is unable to prove their age, as was the case in this instance.'

>> Vote in our latest web poll.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 March 2009 11:25 AM
  • Source: The News
  • Location: Portsmouth
 
Prev
1
2
1

,

03/03/2009 14:52:15
Comment Reported Unsuitable By User
2

simon newsham,

portsmouth 03/03/2009 15:04:39
lunacy, what was the checkout operator thinking? everyone knows fourteen year olds drink vodka not white wine
3

rachel cussell,

portsmouth 03/03/2009 20:49:00
i work in a shop that sells alchol , when you are able to get a fine of up to £5000 , for selling alchol to someone underage of course you are going to be wary of who you are serving , youngsters will drink anything nowadays , if you would be happy paying a fine of £5000 for serving someone underage , then you are the idiot , not the staff at tesco ,
4

Brammers,

Waterlooville 03/03/2009 21:27:40
Common sense really has gone out the window. Here is a mum, shopping with her daughter, wanting to purchase some wine with the food she is buying. Can the staff not see this? While I realise staff can be fined upto £5000 pounds for selling alcohol to underage children, this was not an underage child. This was a 46 year old mum with a child, WHERE IS THE COMMON SENSE?
5

rach.s,

gosport 03/03/2009 21:32:24
i am 20 years old, i went to morrisons and asda with my 40 year old mother and she told her that they could not serve her vodka as i was with her and no id on me.... we was in morrisons with my younger sister (17 yrs old) and on my mothers shopping she had a £7 vodka and i had my own shopping, they asked my sister for id and then as she had no id on her she got refused... she could then put the vodka on to my shopping as i had id on me..even tho they knew she was my mother and my sister. i think it is terrible that they do not sell alcohol to people that look over the age of 18.... or 21 in most shops. my mother is a repectful women that works hard for her money and only because she has short spiked up hair, a nose stud and earrings..there is no reason to JUDGE, as asda and morrisons do, others that are paying customers.
6

xoxAnniexox,

03/03/2009 21:51:18
The problem is, the onus falls on the wrong people. I used to do shopwork and worked on the checkouts, and i was always told to I.D all people when selling alcohol. The problem is now, many parents do buy alcohol for their children, and although it is not fair to tar everyone with the same brush, if that child gets paraleticly drunk and the police find out it was you who sold the drink, it is not the parent, but the shop and the worker who get into trouble! the law needs to change, it is not fair for shop owners and workers to take all responsibility and consequence.
7

Hudo,

Portsmouth 04/03/2009 01:36:54
This is all to do with Proxy sales. Aimed at people buying alcohol for under 18's, I would have thought a mother and her daughter should get through with a bit of commonsense.

The managers or other people should have reassured the checkout person they were right to refer the issue but to allow the sale.
8

Boo22,

Southsea 04/03/2009 16:16:00
I am amazed she paid for the rest of her shopping after putting the two bottles of wine to one side! I would have voted with my feet, left the trolley there and walked off, taken my money elsewhere, Tesco isn't the only supermarket to buy your shopping from, no matter how convenient it might be. Absolutely disgraceful way to treat customers, which is exactly why I never shop in Tesco or Sainsbury's anymore, I'd much rather pay a little extra to a supermarket that appreciates it's customers.
9

3055,

fareham 04/03/2009 17:13:36
maybe it seems trivial to this lady,but if the boot was on the other foot and her daughter had been sold it and got drunk who would she be blaming then.the only reason she was humiliated was the way she behaved,my daughter was instore on the day in question,and i think you will find the cashier was under 18,so would had to get a manager to authorise it,you never her the poor employees go crying to the papers of how some customers treat you like second class citizens,,maybe tesco should have a open day for customers to have a go at being a cashier for the day,and see what them poor cashiers have to put up with.
10

,

04/03/2009 23:06:46
Comment Reported Unsuitable By User
Prev
1
2

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.