Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Tuesday, 9th February 2010

The axe falls on Hart, a luckless boss faced with an impossible task

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
25 November 2009
Just hours earlier, Paul Hart cut a relaxed and good-humoured figure. There was no hint of the fate that was to later befall him.
The subsequent axe clearly surprised Hart as much as anybody.

Taking place at the Wellington Sports Ground, he had just overseen a training session, the first since that Stoke defeat.

Looking back at a tenure which lasted 30 matches, it's hard not to feel some sympathy for a manager who was dogged by misfortune from the outset.

Admittedly, with finances hamstrung, his task was never going to be an easy one.

With star players sold off and without a penny to spend, he had been left with a transfer budget akin to a League Two side rather than one from the Premier League.

After keeping Pompey in the top-flight last term, quite simply he was presented with an impossible mission to repeat his trick.

The penalty miss at the Britannia proved one piece of misfortune too many for Hart.

For a manager dogged by bad luck, there was little chance number 13 would pass without incident.

And so it proved.

The 56-year-old was last night dismissed after the 13th league match of a depressing Blues season.

It was also a game which yielded a 10th defeat.

That was enough to condemn Hart and prompt his Fratton Park exit.

Coincidentally, one of his predecessors, Alain Perrin, had also perished in such circumstances.

Almost four years ago to the day, the Frenchman was sent packing after overseeing a 3-0 defeat at Liverpool.

His 13th match of the league season, it had left the Blues one place above the relegation zone with 10 points.

In comparison, Hart's start to the season was even worse – three points and four places worse to be precise.

As in that 2005-06 campaign, change was needed.

But while Milan Mandaric wielded the axe on that occasion, nobody quite knows whose decision it was ultimately to lever Hart out.

Was is Ali Al Faraj? Or was it Mark Jacob?

Whoever it was, Pompey's current owners will certainly be hoping last night's decision will galvanise the club in the same manner Perrin's replacement did.

As if anyone needs reminding, it was the subsequent arrival of Harry Redknapp in December 2005 which saved the day and sparked the greatest escape of them all.

Now Pompey face the biggest threat to their prized Premier League status since those dark days.

And the hierarchy have acted accordingly.

Not that you will hear too many dissenting voices over Hart's departure, Sunday's Stoke defeat ensured that.

The backlash was a sizeable one, with The News message boards flooded with calls for the manager's head.

Never before had Hart and his on-going performance as Blues boss received such a public mauling as he was set upon from all angles.

At a time when the club are keen to rebuild fraying relationships with supporters, they were not going to bury their heads.

There was little argument his team performed well for him at times, but he suffered enough ill-fortune to keep the Blues anchored to the foot of the table.

In the end, performances of endeavour and positive talking were not enough. It never is in a results industry.

The straight-talking, honest and enduringly dogged Hart had to go in the end, the club's Premier League future matters above all else.

There are now 25 matches to save Pompey's top-flight status, except this time Redknapp is not on the menu.

Whoever is next in the hot seat, let's hope he has better luck than Hart.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 November 2009 7:28 AM
  • Source: The News
  • Location: Portsmouth
 
Prev
1
2
1

mathewpom,

pompey 25/11/2009 12:12:10
noooo he was not unlucky because of his record he was lucky to get the job ,he sighned poor players so good riddens and hopefully the rest of the dead wood will go with him ,IE groves and woan !!!
2

Jo King,

FAREHAM 25/11/2009 12:43:50
Yes! Yes! Yes! And more YES! About time too.
A nice enough guy but never ever a premier league manager.
Forget Man Utd but hopefully Avram Grant will be installed as manager before the Villa game & he will get some quality assistants so Woan & Groves etc can be released as well.
3

Raging Dave,

Portsmouth 25/11/2009 12:44:10
Amazing how terrible footballers/managers tend to be "unlucky"!

Is it unlucky that he bought rubbish players?
Is it unlucky that he picked a hopeless team game after game?
Is it unlucky that he made Mokoena captain of the club?
Is it unlucky that whilst losing, he would regularly leave our best attacking threats on the bench?
Is it unlucky that the only two formations he knew were 4-5-1 and 4-4-2 with the ridiculous diamond midfield?
Is it unlucky that he thought a 1-0 loss was not a bad result because it might come down to goal difference at the end of the season?

The answer to all of these is no - HE WAS HOPELESS.
4

Mikeblue,

25/11/2009 12:59:07
In some ways,I do feel sorry for Paul Hart, who tried to do an impossible job and did it with dignity and to the best of his ability. The simple fact is that he should not have been put in that position, he was never going to be the solution, he was just the cheapest option at the time, much as Adams was before him. With their last two managrial appointments PFC took a cheap and easy option and in each case it has backfired big time. I am convinced it would have saved us money and achieved more had we faced facts when Redknapp left and got ourselves a quality manager then. We wouldnt have had to pay up two severed contracts, and we would have had some sort of continuity and quality at the helm. For pity's sake, Pompey, learn your lesson from the last two mistakes and get it right this time. A top flight club needs a top flight manager, and a struggling top flight club needs one ASAP. Sure a big name quality manager will cost big money, but the alternative is a potential loss of some forty or so million, if we get relegated. It can't be that hard to figure out which is worse, can it?
5

monceau65,

Havant 25/11/2009 13:03:50
Mikeblue:

Well said
6

Andy Weller,

25/11/2009 13:09:34
I agree with the sentiment Mikeblue but we as a club were completely fcvd at the time of appointing Hart.. we were lower than the championship in terms of finance so saying a top flight club needs a top flight manager is obvious but not entirely the full picture.. the same probably goes for TA, no money... although we may have managed to con a more convincing manager in to the post at that time..

Does anyone know if any investment is being made in the team in Jan (or even set up before then if poss)?
7

PompeyBud,

25/11/2009 13:12:19
Matthewpom & Raging Dave - You're both exactly right!
He failed at every post held in lower leagues, yet somehow he was awarded a premiership role and not only that but also, with a limited budget!
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to realise it was never going to work but yet, some deluded fans were convinced he was the man for Pompey! UNBELIVABLE!
8

PompeyBud,

25/11/2009 13:16:54
Mikeblue - Spot on mate!

Lets just hope its a case of third time lucky!
9

mathewpom,

pompey 25/11/2009 13:22:39
pompebud . your eyes are open !!!!!!!!
10

Theobald,

Tesco Town 25/11/2009 13:27:50
I like Paul Hart. Sorry to see him go... Steve Coppell in!!
Prev
1
2

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.