Hospitals under fire on parking revenues

Have your say

NHS hospital trusts have been accused of levying a “tax on sick people” after an investigation revealed some are making more than £3 million a year from car parking fees.

Year on year, hospitals across England are raising increasing amounts of money from staff, patients and visitors, including those who are disabled, the Freedom of Information study by the Press Association found.

Hospitals are also handing over millions of pounds to private firms to run their car parks for them, and allowing some to cash in on parking fines.

Others are tied into private finance initiative (PFI) contracts, where all the money raised from charging ill patients, staff and visitors goes to private firms under lengthy contracts.

Of more than 90 trusts that responded to the FoI request, half are making at least £1 million a year.

The Press Association, which compiled the report, said that Portsmouth Hospitals NHS Trust was not on its list of trusts, which exluded those that did not respond or where annual revenue was lower than £1m.

Seven NHS trusts earned more than £3 million in 2014/15 from charges, a further eight made more than £2 million a year while a further 33 earned more than £1 million a year.

Almost half of all trusts also charged disabled people for parking in some or all of their disabled spaces.

Katherine Murphy, chief executive of the Patients Association, branded the charges “morally wrong”.

She said: “We are concerned that hospitals in England still charge patients for car parking.

“Why is it that patients in Wales and Scotland do not have to pay to park? It is a postcode lottery and a tax on sick people who sometimes struggle to pay.

“The money is never reinvested in frontline services. Hospital car parks are often managed by private contractors who take a huge percentage of the profits.

“This is morally wrong - and charging disabled people is a disgrace.”

Rosie Downes, senior campaigns officer at Macmillan Cancer Support, said: “The core principle of the NHS is to provide free healthcare for all at the point of access.

“But sadly these latest figures show that some cancer patients in England are still paying extortionate hospital car parking charges in order to access treatment for a life-threatening illness.

“Cancer patients receiving vital treatments such as chemotherapy and radiotherapy will often need to make frequent trips to hospital and unaffordable charges are leaving many out of pocket.”

Many trusts defended their revenues, saying some or all of the money was put back into patient care or was spent on maintaining car parks or grounds.

Others claimed their sheer size and the fact that they serve busy neighbourhoods meant they took more in revenue.

University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust raised £3,126,108 from car park charges in 2014/15, up on the £3,002,865 in 2013/14. Since April this year, it has taken an additional £1,316,539.

Meanwhile, Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust raised £3,160,913 in 2014/15, up on the £2,977,109 in 2013/14.

The Heart of England NHS Foundation Trust took £3,413,413 in car park charges in 2014/15. This was less than the previous year, but up on the £2,788,293 in 2011/12.

And Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust raised £3,728,000 net in 2014/15, of which it listed £2,957,000 as “costs” such as running the car park office, security and legal fees.

The investigation found that some hospitals were built under PFI contracts, with all money from parking going to private companies under the terms of the scheme.

At the London North West Healthcare NHS Trust, £1.8 million in 2014 went to the firm Apcoa. It manages the Northwick Park multi-storey under a PFI contract.

Apcoa pays the trust around £40,000 a month on a lease basis, the trust said. The firm also kept £34,052 in parking fines in 2014.

Wye Valley NHS Trust has a PFI contract until 2029, and all its money from patient, visitor and staff parking goes to PFI partner Mercia Healthcare.

Some NHS trusts also raised a significant amount from charging staff for parking. University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust took £3,876,314 in parking charges in 2014/15, of which £1,206,836 was from staff.

The Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust made £424,000 in visitor pay and display income in 2014/15, plus £549,000 from staff parking.

Meanwhile, Northern Lincolnshire and Goole NHS Foundation Trust made £2,159,000, including £22,000 in parking fines and £327,000 from staff.

Shadow health minister Andrew Gwynne said: “When patients go to hospital, the last thing they want to worry about is keeping the car parking ticket up to date. For some patients and their families, the costs can really rack up, which is why these figures are so worrying.

“The last Labour government had a plan to phase out car parking charges, but recent attempts to discuss this matter in Parliament have been blocked by Tory MPs.”

A Department of Health spokeswoman said: “We expect all NHS organisations to follow our guidelines on car parking, including offering discounts to disabled people.

“Patients and families shouldn’t have to deal with the added stress of unfair parking charges and our guidance rightly helps the public hold the NHS to account for any unfair charges or practices.”

Josie Irwin, head of employment relations at the Royal College of Nursing, said: “Nurses regularly work late nights and weekends, and as a result already have to deal with extra costs such as childcare. If they then have to pay excessive charges for car parking it makes a real impact on their pay, which has already fallen far behind the rate of inflation.”

RAC spokesman Simon Williams said: “Our research shows that almost nine in 10 motorists (88%) think parking in hospitals should be free - this view is even more prevalent among those aged 65 or older (93%).”

Matt Harper, a father of one from Sutton Coldfield, Birmingham, who is expecting his second child in the new year, has been visiting relatives at Heart of England NHS Foundation Trust’s Good Hope Hospital.

“I think it is disgraceful,” said the mechanic.

“You go there to visit a loved one and they charge stupid amounts of money for just a couple of hours.

“I had a baby last year and we were in there for three days and the parking charges were about £25-£30, at £5 every time when we were there at least twice a day.

“But what they didn’t tell you is when I spoke to another patient, they had a pass which was something like £10 for three days and they don’t advertise that, and I think if they did more people would do that instead of ripping them off every time.”

The 26-year-old added the story was the same at other hospitals, when his family endured four weeks of charges at three separate sites when his father needed a heart bypass.

Mr Harper explained: “He was originally at Good Hope, then Heartlands (Hospital) and then the Walsgrave in Coventry.

“The charges then were absolutely horrendous and he was up there for four weeks.”

Another visitor to Good Hope, Claire Riches, said the charges were unfair and it was never made explicitly clear to the public where all the money ended up.

The 47-year-old said: “It’s totally unfair and I don’t think you’ll find anybody that will say that is fair.

“It’s a sneaky way of getting extra money in, and nobody knows where it actually goes.

“I mean there’s obviously a firm making a profit from this, effectively a profit from people being ill and visiting their family and friends.”

Asked whether there was any alternative to the current system, she added: “The only thing I can think of is you introduce some very low, reasonable parking charges, if you have to charge at all.”

Mark Neal, interim head of estates at Oxford University Hospitals, said: “Oxford University Hospitals is one of the biggest hospital trusts in the country, running four hospitals on different sites with 1,600 patient car parking spaces and over a million contacts with our patients every year.

“Our car parking charges are lower than many other hospitals and in keeping with car parking charges locally.

“We have not increased our hourly rate of parking for two years and before that we hadn’t increased it for 10 years.”

He added: “We have to charge for car parking both to cover the costs of maintaining our car parks (otherwise we would have to use money that would be spent on patient care) and in an area of high demand for car parking in order to deter people from using our car parks for purposes other than visiting our hospitals.”