There’s a whole heap of unanswered questions

Share this article
Friends and family released balloons on Portsdown Hill on what would have been Katie's 15th birthday on February 4

CHERYL GIBBS: Inspirational Katie touched the hearts of so many in her short life

Have your say

So how would you react if you were asked to pay to send your child to a state school?

A few weeks ago Dr Anthony Seldon, an educationalist and biographer of Tony Blair, published a pamphlet that suggested exactly that.

He said families earning more than £80,000 a year should have to pay something to go to a popular state school, with those earning £200,000 plus paying the full cost. There’d be a super premium charged for the most popular schools too.

To many this may sound like something worth thinking about, but I’d like to persuade you it’s a lousy idea – that something as seemingly simple as this is a nightmare for a government to implement and how, in the long run, it would almost certainly be self-defeating anyway.

Consider for a moment these simple variables: what do we mean by a family income of £80,000; what do we mean by the ‘full cost’ of school; what do we mean by the ‘most popular’; what do we do if someone’s income changes; what happens if a school becomes less ‘popular’; how do teachers react to those parents paying, as opposed to those not paying? What would be the response of the private school market to this change?

And that’s just a few off the top of my head! My point here is that for every simple-looking idea out there that seems like a great solution to a problem, there is a whole heap of unanswered questions swimming along behind.