The Blues skipper demonstrated his importance to Kenny Jackett again on Saturday by popping up to score in the 1-0 win against Bradford.
His winner was his fifth goal of the season, placing him third in Pompey's current goalscoring charts.
Evans joined Pompey as a triallist in 2015 and currently sits on 149 appearances for the club.
This summer sees the end of the 30-year-old's contract, alongside those of Jack Whatmough, Nathan Thompson, Dion Donohue and Danny Rose.
The Blues revealed in The News last month that contract talks are on hold until the new year.
But we've been asking fans whether Evans' future should be decided now with a new deal?
Here's what supporters haveÂ been saying on our Facebook page '“Â Portsmouth FC '“Â The News...
He actually covered at least fiveÂ different positions in the same game on Saturday '“Â Â vice-capt, stand-in skipper, defender, midfielderÂ & striker all rolled into one!.
So my current response is definitely a yes, as he recently made it very clear that he & his Wife are really happy & settled here now.
He's not Championship quality unfortunately. If we go up he would be a dead weight.
I'd give him another year now.Â Is he Championship quality, possibly not, but we are a long way off from getting there yet anyway.
A new contract extensionÂ gives him security that he has earned with his versatility, work-rate and consistency.
100-per-centÂ class act on and off the pitch.
Definitely. He can play all positions and always gives 100 per cent.
Would be a dead weight? Oh dear!Â Really?
Love the guy, give him another 10 years!
Yes he does forÂ sure.
For me he plays an important part in the team.Â No tantrums when he was dropped, he dug in, trained hard and earned his place back.
Gareth Evans is a blue is a blue is a blue. Sign him up.
Difficult.Â Never really understood his real football talents.Â But he seems to make a team work!
In my mind he does give a certain authority to others around him, as a footballerÂ I'm not so sure where he fits, but IÂ do know he loves Pompey and he seems to bring the best out of us when he's there!
Good for Pompey as it stands? YES for me!
But long term championship player? Not!