Substitute Gareth Evans, Brett Pitman, Lee Brown, Jamal Lowe and Oli Hawkins netted from the spot as the Blues won 5-4 in the shoot-out after it finished 2-2 after extra-time.
Here’s chief sports writer Neil Allen’s Pompey player ratings
5. tds_pompey_sunderland_final310319_070.JPG
Outstanding first half and contained that display for the remainder of the match. A constant attacking outlet down the left and defensively sound throughout, ensuring few escaped down his side - 8
Photo: Joe Pepler
6. jx1_0653_2019033134304548.jpg
Marginalised in the first-half but was instrumental in Pompey’s resurrection as they dictated play from half-time onwards. What a wonderful occasion for Pompey fan who watched the 2008 FA Cup win from the stands - 8 (113 mins Anton Walkes)
Photo: Jordan Mansfield
7. jx1_0881_2019033142203429.jpg
Provided a magnificent shield in front of the defence, particularly during the first half when Blues were under so much intense pressure. Severely under-rated player who always stands up when his team needs him - 9
Photo: Jordan Mansfield
8. jx1_0623_2019033134154452.jpg
A touch of class to give Pompey the lead in extra-time from a player who became more dangerous as the game progressed. His quick feet down the right and pace made him a constant threat - and he demonstrated his finishing quality with his 14th of the season - 8
Photo: Jordan Mansfield