Bishop's Waltham attempted murder: Woman jailed after trying to kill her friend over £3,900 bingo debt

A WOMAN who attempted to murder her bingo pal by ‘slitting her throat’ so she wouldn’t be exposed for stealing almost £4,000 has been jailed for 14 years.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

Vicious Paula Ayres was locked up after being convicted by a jury yesterday for the brutal stabbing of 63-year-old friend, Julie Page.

The 51-year-old mother-of-three left her unsuspecting pal ‘for dead’ after launching a bloody, prolonged assault in Mrs Page’s home, in Oak Road, Bishop’s Waltham, on July 22, last year.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Part-time cleaner Ayres, who refused to give evidence during her trial, remained motionless as she was jailed.

Paula Ayres Picture: Hampshire ConstabularyPaula Ayres Picture: Hampshire Constabulary
Paula Ayres Picture: Hampshire Constabulary

Sentencing Judge Roger Hetherington said: ‘It was inevitable that you would have been caught out. It says something about your mental state that you didn’t seem to realise this at all.’

The court heard how Ayres snapped in an ‘explosion of anger’ after realising she had been ‘rumbled’ for pilfering £3,900 from Mrs Page’s marital bank account.

The scheming crook used her regular Sunday bingo trips in Eastleigh to snatch Mrs Page’s card and withdraw money from a nearby cash machine.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Ayres feared she had been caught after overhearing a conversation between Mrs Page and a family member about the thefts while round her pal’s house.

Police at the scene of an incident in Oak Road in Bishop's Waltham on July 22. Picture: Tom CotterillPolice at the scene of an incident in Oak Road in Bishop's Waltham on July 22. Picture: Tom Cotterill
Police at the scene of an incident in Oak Road in Bishop's Waltham on July 22. Picture: Tom Cotterill

In a bid to silence her friend of six years, calculating Ayres left to grab a Stanley knife from her home before returning to her victim’s house to carry out her chilling ambush.

Ayres used a ‘ruse’ to send away mutual friend Angela Edwards, asking her to fetch some Coffee Mate so the coast was clear to murder Mrs Page.

The twisted thief then launched a relentless attack that saw her plunge the knife into her helpless victim’s neck twice after ‘lunging at her from behind’ and holding her head in a ‘vice-like grip’.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

She then stabbed her prey five times in the back and ripped her ear when pulling out an earring.

Read More
Bishop's Waltham attempted murder victim tells court about the moment her friend...

Mrs Page said during her evidence: ‘She put her hands around my neck. I thought “Christ what’s going on?”.

‘I said to Paula: “What’s wrong with you? Why are you doing this?”.’

The victim was then forced to ‘play dead’ before Ayres left her on the floor – only to be arrested by police shortly after, having put the knife in her washing machine to cover-up her crime.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

‘The stabbing to the neck resulted in two deep and gaping wounds, graphically shown in photographs, and copious amounts of blood – some of which got onto you and a towel which you wrapped around the knife,’ added Judge Hetherington.

‘You pretended to Angela Edwards that you just cut yourself on a tin opener and returned with her to your own house, put the towel and knife in the washing machine and carried on as if nothing had happened.’

Weeks before the attack, Ayres had been convicted of three counts of fraud after she was caught stealing from a vulnerable 86-year-old pensioner, Leslie Smith.

Ayres, who was a ‘trusted family friend’ used Mr Smith’s bank card in 2016 to siphon £2,337.62 from her victim’s savings ‘for her own personal gain’, prosecutor Simon Jones said.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

A total of £1,590 went towards paying Winchester City Council bills, with £550 given to Ross & Roberts bailiffs and £197.62 was used to pay back a loan by Amigo.

Judge Hetherington said Ayres feared she would be jailed if reported to police.

‘It is understandable that as a result you would have become extremely worried...What is inexplicable by any ordinary standard is why, faced with that understandable worry, you lost all sense of proportion and were determined to carry out a vicious assault against Julie Page,’ he told a packed courtroom.

‘Had you been thinking straight you would have realised that it would have had no hope of putting an end to the investigation of the theft. But you were not thinking straight.’

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Paul Casey, defending, said he could offer ‘no mitigation’ for the ‘extremely grave offence’.

However, he said his client had suffered years of depression and prolonged grief after the stillbirth of her fourth child in 2008.

Pleading for mercy, Mr Casey added: ‘She is the author of her own misfortune and the author of a great deal of misfortune to other innocent victims who trusted her and regarded her as a friend.

‘She has thrown away everything that is positive in her life and will spend the next part of her life – important years for her children – in custody.’

Judge Hetherington took Ayres’ mental health into account when sentencing.

The 51-year-old, of Willow Road, Bishop’s Waltham, will now serve seven years in prison before being released on licence.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.