Louise Smith's killer Shane Mays told an audacious 'pack of lies' and claimed memories had 'vanished'

KILLER Shane Mays’ merciless brutality in murdering his wife’s niece is only matched in its horror by the audacity of the ‘pack of lies’ he spun in the aftermath.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

Mays has learning disabilities, a personality disorder and an IQ of just 63. He needed a break every 40 minutes while giving evidence at Winchester Crown Court.

He played Xbox - Fortnite, Call of Duty, Need for Speed - for nine hours a day.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Prosecutor James Newton-Price QC said Mays was ‘crafty’ and capable of deliberately lying to police to try and throw them off the scent as Louise lay dead in Havant Thicket.

Shane Mays. Picture: Hampshire ConstabularyShane Mays. Picture: Hampshire Constabulary
Shane Mays. Picture: Hampshire Constabulary

Giving evidence at his trial, he both admitted lying and denied it. He pleaded guilty to manslaughter but denied killing Louise at all.

Read More
Louise Smith trial: ‘Pure evil’ Shane Mays jailed for at least 25 years with lif...

It wasn’t possible for him to lie, he suggested, as his memory had vanished.

He claimed he searched Waterlooville, Rowlands Castle, Hayling Island, Leigh Park, and Langstone for Louise. He was asked why? To find Louise or her body?

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Mays, who admits having a temper, said: ‘To find Louise because I had no memory of what I’d done.’

It was only in Bristol jail in June, having been arrested on May 27, that he said he remembered ‘everything’. But still he denied defiling and burning her body. Mays told his family he took Louise to Emsworth skate park.

He told police he said goodbye to her on Billy Lawn Avenue.

Did he lie? No, he just didn’t remember. Why did he give different versions of when he last saw Louise? Did he have ‘false memories?’ Yes, he said.

Despite admitting manslaughter, he told jurors repeatedly: ‘I did not kill Louise.’

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

In the words of prosecutor James Newton-Price QC he ‘simply cannot face’ what he did - attacking the teenager in a fit of rage with murderous intent.

A message from the Editor, Mark Waldron

You can subscribe here for unlimited access to Portsmouth news online - as well as fewer adverts, access to our digital edition and mobile app.

Our trial offer starts at just £2 a month for the first two months.