Sonia Exelby: Murder accused went by name of ‘Alpha Sadist’ as court trial begins
The trial is expected to last until the end of the week
A man accused of murdering a Southsea woman who allegedly flew to America to be killed was known as “Alpha Sadist”.
Dwain Hall, 54, is accused of kidnapping and murdering Sonia Exelby, 32, in October 2025 after they linked up on a now defunct fetish website called “Motherless.com”.
.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

“Kind” Sonia was found stabbed to death and buried in woods in Marion County, Florida, on October 17 last year after going missing from Southsea days earlier on October 12. She had been found stabbed four times.
Sonia, a music tutor, was allegedly groomed into travelling to Florida to meet with Hall who promised to violently kill her if she paid him $4,000 (£3,000).
Hall, a married roadside mechanic from Ocala, appeared in court on Monday to attend the jury selection hearing for his trial this week. He denies Sonia’s kidnap and murder.
Hall and Exelby had communicated for about two years on Motherless.com - where Hall went by the moniker “Alpha Sadist” - as well as on an encrypted application called Sessions, Marion County Judicial Centre was reportedly told.
Motherless featured “content that depicted various fetishes, including extreme BDSM, torture, and rape material,” according to court documents.
During their exchanges, Exelby, who reportedly struggled with mental health issues, allegedly expressed a desire to be murdered.
Messages exchanged between the pair, along with images recovered from Hall’s phone, will be used by the prosecution to prove their case.
Amy Beth Berndt, the lead prosecutor, told the court Sonia’s two sisters, Gemma Isaj and Sara Exelby, and her fiancé Stevie Hunt, had been called to give evidence at the trial about Sonia’s circumstances and personal life.


Mr Hunt, a graffiti artist from Portsmouth who lived with Ms Exelby, will be testifying via video-link because of health conditions.
Hall appeared wearing a grey button-down dress shirt, grey trousers and glasses. He spoke only to confirm he understood proceedings. Hall, who is represented by defence lawyer Junior Barrett, denies the charges.
The trial is set to last for four days with jurors beginning their deliberations on Friday. The prosecution will open the case on Tuesday.
Florida currently executes more convicted murderers than any other US state but prosecutors will not seek the death penalty in Hall’s case.
According to The Telegraph, British authorities agreed to share evidence with US prosecutors only on condition that the death penalty would not be pursued.