‘Weird’ murder accused beat Sonia Exelby and was last person to see her alive, court hears

Dwain Hall claimed he was being “set up”

A “weird” murder accused beat a Southsea woman and was the last person to see her alive after she allegedly flew to America to be killed, a court heard.

Dwain Hall, 54, who went by the online username of Alpha Sadist, stands accused of murdering Sonia Exelby, 32, who was found by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on October 17 last year.

Screenshot of Dwain Hall in the dock during the murder trial placeholder image
Screenshot of Dwain Hall in the dock during the murder trial | Court TV/Youtube

“Predator” Hall, who is on trial in Florida for first-degree murder and kidnapping, had demanded Sonia pay 4,000 dollars (£3,000) for him to kill her when she travelled to the US last October, the trial previously heard.

Giving evidence at Marion County Judicial Centre, special agent Rebekah McKinzie said Hall, of Ocala, admitted during interview he had sex with Sonia twice when they were staying at an Airbnb in Reddick prior to her death. “He said it was rough with choking. He told me he hit her on the front and the back which included her breasts her face and her (bottom),” she told the court.

The agent also revealed that Hall confessed taking a video of Sonia on his phone which he then deleted because she was “not behaving right”.

Asked if Hall ever admitted to killing Sonia, agent McKensie said: “He did not come out and say he had killed her but he indicated he was the last person to see her alive and that he had disposed of some of her items in a donation bin which we were able to recover.

“He put himself at the place where we found Sonia’s body where it had been buried. He also made a comment when we were questioning him that if you take somebody’s life that’s murder.”

Video evidence played to the trial of Dwain Hall being quizzed by detectivesplaceholder image
Video evidence played to the trial of Dwain Hall being quizzed by detectives | Court TV/Youtube screenshot

Asked if ever said whether he helped Sonia get what she wanted the agent said: “Yes he did.”

When Sonia’s body was discovered in Marion Oaks, near where the defendant lived, she was found with just a bra and sandals on with her dress “laid on top of her”, agent McKensie said.

Meanwhile Hall’s video interview with police was shown to the court in which he claimed he was being “set up”.

The defendant, becoming defensive when detectives ask to see his phone, is asked whether he had “some weird stuff” on his device to which he responds: “What do you think?”

When asked if perhaps he was defending himself when Sonia was killed, Hall said: “No matter how I answer any of these questions it’s not going to look well right?”

The detective replies: “You continuing not to answer questions and not be up front about it isn’t making you look well.”

Sonia Exelby placeholder image
Sonia Exelby | Family

Hall went on to say after striking up chats with Sonia online he became her “mentor”, adding: “I wanted to make her life better. I didn’t want her to kill herself.”

He said Sonia offered to “help me with a lot of money” and I said “yes”.

Hall said he and Sonia made up a “cover story” together. “She insisted that she did not want to be a burden to me or my wife in the process of getting her mutants. And I was very appreciative of that and just wanted to help her,” he said.

“After she came here she didn’t want to be bothered by the trainings of humanity, so to speak, anymore. She wanted it to be done. She didn’t want to be bothered.”

Jurors also heard from Sonia’s sister, Fareham based Gemma Isaj. Asked if she knew whether Sonia had got involved with “some people online that were offering to kill her” on the dark web Gemma said she was aware of the predicament. In November 2023 at a family gathering, Gemma recalled speaking to her sister about her troubles.

She told the court: “She told me she got into something and she was really terrified and that people had been making some horrible threats to her and against the family and knew where she was and could locate her.

“Sonia said that she had gone onto suicide forums for support and there were people who were preying on Sonia and her friends. Sonia said she was trying to gather evidence because she couldn't bear that people were being hurt and she said that she needed to do this to gather evidence to stop these things happening to other people.

“I phoned the police in that moment. I could see how scared she was.”

Sonia Exelby’s sister Gemma Isaj giving evidence at the trial placeholder image
Sonia Exelby’s sister Gemma Isaj giving evidence at the trial | Court TV/Youtube screenshot

Gemma told jurors Sonia had been threatened by several individuals - none of whom were from the UK.

On October 10 2025 the siblings were due to meet up which they were all “excited” about but Sonia did not show up. “I didn’t think much about it”, Gemma said, adding it was “common” for Sonia not to show up to planned meet-ups.

On October 12 she learned that Sonia was missing after her boyfriend Stevie Hunt had got in touch - with it “very concerning” her missing for two days.

After discovering Sonia had flown to Florida Gemma wrote a post and put it on Florida sites because she knew how “vulnerable” she was.

After contacting Hampshire police, Gemma was told they were “looking into” Sonia’s disappearance. Asked if she spoke to any police officers at that time Gemma said she had not, adding: “They didn’t come back to me at that time.”

(Proceeding)

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice