Ex-Royal Navy chief blasts government’s ‘meaningless’ stance on defence

DEFENCE pledges made by the government have been branded ‘meaningless’ by a furious former head of the Royal Navy.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

In a scathing broadside on Whitehall, Admiral Lord Alan West blasted Downing Street for ‘insulting’ cuts on military coffers.

The furious navy chief’s critique comes after the Queen’s Speech, in which the monarch outlined Boris Johnson’s future spending plans.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Lord West, who was a former security advisor to Labour PM Gordon Brown, fumed that only a passing reference had been made about defence in the address – 26 words in all.

Admiral Lord Alan West, former First Sea Lord and security minister.Admiral Lord Alan West, former First Sea Lord and security minister.
Admiral Lord Alan West, former First Sea Lord and security minister.

In a fiery retort at the House of Lords, the outspoken Labour peer said: ‘The statement that: “My government will continue to invest in our gallant armed forces” is meaningless.

‘There are presumably idealists who would not wish to invest in our armed forces, but in this very dangerous world, while we may try to avoid conflict, the same, I am afraid, is not true of everyone whom we confront in this world.’

During September’s spending review, the Ministry of Defence was given £2.2bn, a rise of 2.6 per cent.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

But the military is still facing a huge funding crisis shortfall.

More than £4bn of naval kit in one photo - aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth pictured with destroyer HMS Dragon. Photo: LPhot Daniel ShepherdMore than £4bn of naval kit in one photo - aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth pictured with destroyer HMS Dragon. Photo: LPhot Daniel Shepherd
More than £4bn of naval kit in one photo - aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth pictured with destroyer HMS Dragon. Photo: LPhot Daniel Shepherd

In February, the public accounts committee, the House of Commons’ spending watchdog, warned the MoD faced a £7bn black hole in its 10-year plan to equip the armed forces.

Lord West backed a review to ‘assess the nation’s place in the world’ but demanded ‘clarity’ on Britain’s foreign policy now that ‘so many of the old certainties’ had ‘disappeared and been replaced by confusion’.

He branded previous strategic defence and security reviews in 2010 and 2015 ‘incoherent cost-cutting exercises with little regard to strategy or strategic thought’.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

‘It seems that our political culture recognises only as much threat as it is willing to spend money on, rather than the realities of the world,’ the Falklands veteran said.

Soldiers from 4th Battalion, The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment based in Cosham, on exercise in Denmark. Photo: Corporal Ben Beale.





Soldiers from 4th Battalion The Princess of Wales’s Royal Regiment (4 PWRR) have been taking part in Exercise Viking Star, which is a reciprocal, joint exercise with the Danish Army. Approximately 100 Reservists from across the South of England have deployed to Denmark to train and exercise as part of the multinational force whilst building strong bonds, a positive reputation amongst our allies and remaining combat ready and adaptable. Elements of the exercise include, Section and Platoon Attacks, Live Fire Ranges using UK and Danish Weapons and operating in built up areas (OBUA training) using a purpose built village and simulation ammunition (high powered paint filled rounds) they also practice patrolling, training for their battalion specialist patrol and reconnaissance teams and cultural familiarity. 


  
Photographer:
Corporal Ben Beale/ MoD CrownSoldiers from 4th Battalion, The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment based in Cosham, on exercise in Denmark. Photo: Corporal Ben Beale.





Soldiers from 4th Battalion The Princess of Wales’s Royal Regiment (4 PWRR) have been taking part in Exercise Viking Star, which is a reciprocal, joint exercise with the Danish Army. Approximately 100 Reservists from across the South of England have deployed to Denmark to train and exercise as part of the multinational force whilst building strong bonds, a positive reputation amongst our allies and remaining combat ready and adaptable. Elements of the exercise include, Section and Platoon Attacks, Live Fire Ranges using UK and Danish Weapons and operating in built up areas (OBUA training) using a purpose built village and simulation ammunition (high powered paint filled rounds) they also practice patrolling, training for their battalion specialist patrol and reconnaissance teams and cultural familiarity. 


  
Photographer:
Corporal Ben Beale/ MoD Crown
Soldiers from 4th Battalion, The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment based in Cosham, on exercise in Denmark. Photo: Corporal Ben Beale. Soldiers from 4th Battalion The Princess of Wales’s Royal Regiment (4 PWRR) have been taking part in Exercise Viking Star, which is a reciprocal, joint exercise with the Danish Army. Approximately 100 Reservists from across the South of England have deployed to Denmark to train and exercise as part of the multinational force whilst building strong bonds, a positive reputation amongst our allies and remaining combat ready and adaptable. Elements of the exercise include, Section and Platoon Attacks, Live Fire Ranges using UK and Danish Weapons and operating in built up areas (OBUA training) using a purpose built village and simulation ammunition (high powered paint filled rounds) they also practice patrolling, training for their battalion specialist patrol and reconnaissance teams and cultural familiarity. Photographer: Corporal Ben Beale/ MoD Crown

Repeated warnings that there wasn’t ‘sufficient’ cash in defence had been ignored ‘time and time again’, Lord West said

‘I am afraid that there is a large lobby, including senior officials in Whitehall. who are willing to take ever greater risks with the defence of our nation,’ he added.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.