Why Kenny Jackett's staying as manager for now, how he could yet be sacked, has he lost dressing room and why Gareth Evans left - your Portsmouth questions answered
and live on Freeview channel 276
Are the board/owners even considering getting a new manager?
Andy Slater
Only one place to start this week, and it’s with Andy’s question which has been echoed many times over by you, mainly with less printable variants.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdYou may have seen we’ve revealed this afternoon that Jackett is to remain as Pompey manager, a story which gives a lot of background to the subject of his future.
It worth starting by making the point that the frustration which escalated on Saturday, are emotions being echoed among the club’s board.
The performance against Wigan wasn’t good enough. The start to the season hasn’t been good enough.
Whatever the strength of feeling among fans, though, the board's view is it's too early to pull the trigger after three league games, but they certainly know what’s taken place so far isn’t acceptable.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdSo yes, it’s too early in the season, but let’s not pretend this decision isn’t also about the desperate state football finds itself in.
Sacking the manager simply doesn’t make economic sense at present.
The club have now lost over £5m through the Covid crisis, losses which are being propped up by the Eisners.
It doesn’t take a financial expert to realise those losses can’t be sustained, and Mark Catlin has already indicated he can’t rule out redundancies.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdIf the club were to sack Jackett it would cost circa £400,000 and, of course, there’s the additional costs of paying up backroom staff, potentially compensating a club for a new manager and then the likely ensuing player turnover.
How does paying out that kind of money align with potentially having to make loyal staff redundant?
It may not be what supporters want to hear, but Kenny is going nowhere.
To be clear it’s not just a financial decision, but in the crisis Pompey and football are facing they feel now is not the right time for a change.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdWill the club honour KJ’s contract until the end of the season or is there a possibility he could get sacked if the slow start continues?
Elliot Miller
Continuing with the theme of Kenny’s future, but more with a focus on timescale with Elliot’s question.
As I said previously, I think the club view it as too early to sack Kenny, especially after three league games.
If they did it now, it would smack of a knee-jerk decision, which is definitely not the Eisner’s way.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdIf they were going to sack the manager they would have done it after the Oxford United play-off defeat, instead of backing his recruitment all summer and doing it now. I could certainly imagine Milan Mandaric going down that route back in the day, however!
The vibe I get is that if Pompey were down the wrong end of the table when it gets to November time, they could still act. So the eight games in October are huge.
There’s been a few people saying why won’t the manager walk? Forget that, he has a contract until next summer and will expect it to be honoured.
Obviously, if it got to the end of the season and the club didn’t go up, there would be a parting of the ways at the contract’s end.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdBottom line, as Jackett said himself, he knows the business he’s in and the rules of the game. If things don’t improve he’s aware of the outcome.
Has the chief executive explained to the owners the strength of opinion gathering against the management team and how toxic things can become at a football club when situations are allowed to continue?
Mike Flannagan
Only one talking point this week isn’t there!
I don’t think Mark Catlin needs to tell the board about the strength of feeling among supporters at present.
Toxic is a term which is being bandied around a lot, and it’s certainly an accurate one to describe how Fratton Park would be if fans were present. It would be AFC Wimbledon away last season on steroids.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdSo perhaps the manager is lucky that games are taking place without fans.
That’s possibly the case in more than one way, because if supporters were allowed to attend and they voted with their feet by staying away, I could picture that being a scenario which would force them to act over his future.
Has Kenny lost the dressing room?
Rory Jones
This is a subject which has once again reared its head after the weekend.
I wrote back in August I felt one of Kenny Jackett’s biggest challenges was to repair fractures in the dressing room after the events of last season.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdWithout naming names, it’s fair to say there would have been a lot of people alienated by decisions made last term over selection and tactics.
That issue has been brought into focus by the season’s start and it was interesting to see someone with Guy Whittingham’s experience suggesting it didn’t look like the players were trying for their manager on Saturday.
The term ‘lost the dressing room’ is a strong one. Perhaps it’s a combination of past events, lack of confidence, belief and leadership coming together in a perfect storm of negativity for the players.
Whatever it is, that dressing room now needs to stand up and show its character.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdWas Evans moving on to do with being dropped again by Kenny?
Rory Jones
Two questions from Rory this week, but two good ‘uns and we have to tackle the subject of Gaz Evans departing.
It was disappointing to hear of his impending departure last Thursday, and I think the outpouring of affection showed how fans felt. It certainly meant the world to the man himself.
Basically, Evans departed because he was told he wasn’t going to feature this season - especially after Michael Jacobs’ arrival.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdHe was informed he would be back up and it would take a number of injuries or a scenario like the squad to be decimated by Covid-19, to get him into the team.
From Jackett’s view, he obviously feels the player’s wages and position in the squad under the wage cap may be better utilised elsewhere - like a deeper midfielder, for example.
So maybe it was a move which was best for all parties, but, from a personal standpoint it was just very sad to see Gaz go - and I thank him for the memories.
A message from the Editor, Mark Waldron
Thank you for reading this story. The News has launched a new subscription offer which gives you unlimited access to all of our Pompey coverage.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdYou can subscribe here to get the latest updates from Fratton Park, transfer news and expert analysis from our team of Pompey writers.
Every subscription helps us continue providing trusted, local journalism on your behalf for our city
Comment Guidelines
National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.