Proceed with yet more caution - the alternative Portsmouth match ratings are in

We asked our followers on Facebook to supply us with their match ratings from today’s Papa John’s Trophy final defeat at the hands of Salford.

Saturday, 13th March 2021, 8:20 pm
Updated Tuesday, 16th March 2021, 9:15 am
Craig MacGillivray looks dejected at the final whistle but will take comfort from the praise he has received from fans following his Wembley heroics.

The News’ ratings always create plenty of debate, so we thought – why not let you provide us with you’re big-game scores.

And as always you didn’t let us down, with plenty of fans joining in with their takes on individual performances.

As you’d expect, keeper Craig MacGillivray was deemed pretty much faultless throughout the game, with his heroics earning him scores of nines and 10s.

Sign up to our Portsmouth FC newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

Yet, as is always the case, there were plenty of alternative perspectives on the rest on the team.

Here’s some of the match ratings we received...

Andy Skelton

This content is brought to you in association with the University of Portsmouth

MacGillivray 9, Bolton 6, Whatmough 6, Raggett 6, Daniels 4, Williams 7, Naylor 6, Byers 5, White 4, Marquis 5, Hiwula 6. Subs: Brown 7, Harness 6, Close 7, Curtis 6.

Jason Hall

MacGillivray 9 - excellent, Bolton 6 - delivery poor, Whatmough 7 - solid, Raggett 6 - average, Daniels 2 - useless, Williams 7- good, Naylor 5 - looks pissed off, Byers 2- ****, White 3 - poor, Marquis 4 - not good enough, Hiwula 3 - pants, Close 5- ok, Curtis 5 - tried, Harness- 6 tried, Brown - 7 looked good, Jacobs - 4 no impact.

Gav Jones

MacGillivray 10, Bolton 7, Whatmough 8, Raggett 6, Daniels 6, Williams 7, Naylor 7, Byers 6, White 6, Marquis 6, Hiwula 6, Curtis 7, Harness 7, Brown 7, Close 8.

Andy Legg

MacGillivray 10, Bolton 3, Whatmough 5, Raggett 2, Daniels 2, Williams 6, Naylor 3, Byers 2, White 2, Marquis 3, Hiwula 3, Brown 5, Harness 5, Close 5, Curtis 4.

Richard Twose

MacGillivray 10, Brown 9, Williams 8, Naylor 8. After that what is the point.

Harry Greest

MacGillivray 10 - Unbelievable would of been game over by half time if it wasn’t for him.

Bolton 7 - Looked good going forward.

Whatmough 8 - Solid at the back.

Raggett 6 - Pony.

Daniels 5 - Nearly as bad as the quality he’s brought since joining.

Williams 7 - Spells of good attacking play shocking penalty.

Naylor 7 - Wasn’t too bad in the middle.

Byers 5 - ****

White 6 - Average didn’t do much wrong nor right.

Marquis 5 - Awful as per service didn’t help him.

Hiwula 5 - Poor service seemed too lose the ball a lot.

Curtis 6 - Played well, definitely made a difference when he came on should of squared it too Marquis and as for the penalty...

Harness 7 - Only forward player with urgency going forward.

Brown 9 - Thought he had a very good game when he came on.

Close 5 - Average

Leonardo Colford

Big Mac 10, Close 8 and everyone else 0.

Dave Smith

Easy, Big Mac 100, the rest -200.

Trevor Harvey

MacGillivray 10, Bolton 4, Whatmough 4, Raggett 1, Daniels 3, Williams 6, Naylor 5, Byers 4, White 4, Marquis 4, Hiwula 4, Brown 4, Harness 5, Close 4, Curtis 4.

A message from the Editor, Mark Waldron

On Saturday, March 13 Pompey will finally get their day at Wembley.

To celebrate the Blues’ place in the rearranged 2020 EFL Trophy Final, The News has launched an offer that gets you 25% off all our Sports subscriptions.

You can choose your perfect Sports subscription here and use the discount code ROADTOWEMBLEY25 to get the latest news from Fratton Park for less. Offer runs until midnight on March 15.