Exclusive:Bolton 1 Portsmouth 1: Neil Allen’s verdict - Returning hero’s romantic story spoilt, but future so bright
The influential winger’s first goal since March 2025 also marked his first Blues start in 11 months
During his post-match interviews, Josh Murphy stressed a preference not to reflect on his recent injury history, a polite request delivered with impeccable manners.
It's entirely understandable, admirable even, that the talented winger wishes to focus ahead rather than dredge up a painful past 18 months which has devastated his Fratton Park career.


At his glorious peak, the classy ex-Norwich man swept the board at the 2024-25 end of season awards, claiming 14 in total, including The News/Sports Mail’s Player of the Season and Players’ Player of the Season.
Since then, he has totalled 22 appearances, including Saturday’s 1-1 draw at Bolton, with a succession of injuries depriving Pompey of their best winger since their Premier League heyday.
As it so happened, Murphy’s first start in 11 months would yield a first goal since March 2025, when he netted the match winner against Blackburn.
Granted, if the Toughsheet Stadium is to mark the rebirth of the 31-year-old, it serves little purpose dwelling on the past and reliving those cruel set-backs. Certainly in the eyes of Pompey’s popular number 23.
Too much precious time has already been lost - and how the Fratton faithful are eager to embrace the latest comeback of an irreplaceable talisman. Hopefully this time it is permanent.
Failing to replicate his quality
In Murphy’s ongoing absence, Colby Bishop’s once golden goal-scoring touch has declined significantly, with the likes of Florian Bianchini, Harvey Blair, Minhyeok Yang and Gustavo Caballero failing to replicate his quality from out wide.
Abu Kamara is trying his best, yet continues to frustrate, Adrian Segecic has had plenty of good moments, while Keshi Anderson’s undoubtable effectiveness has been blunted by repeated injury.


Yet none can possibly compare to a fully-fit and flying Josh Murphy.
Perhaps Bolton will signal the fresh start his Fratton Park career so desperately needs, providing the launchpad for one of the Championship’s finest wingers to thrive once more, roared on by fans who adore him.
Among two changes for the trip to Bolton, it took just seven minutes for the attacker to register, following excellent work from Terry Devlin down the right.
Dispossessing Max Conway, the Northern Ireland international produced a wonderful deep cross which was met by a flying header by Murphy to hand the Blues the lead.
He later admitted it was only the second headed goal of his career, nonetheless it capped a superb move and no doubt represented an emotional moment for the former Cardiff man, who surely now deserves some good fortune in his football life.
Nicolas Schmid spoiled the day
Of course, it would be too perfect to have been the match winner, far too convenient. Football never works like that, irrespective of the perpetual need for romanticism in its plotting.


Just five minutes later, Nicolas Schmid stole the limelight, albeit unintentionally. Still, it would be his name the Fratton faithful would be talking about afterwards rather than the returning hero.
Sam Dalby was allowed to twist and turn inside the box and return the ball to Conway on the left, with the full-back taking a touch and drilling a low cross into the box.
The striker met it with a first-time shot, which, despite lacking power, managed to sneak through Schmid’s legs at his near post and find a way through for an equaliser.
The Austrian’s starting spot had previously come under scrutiny before Saturday. Now, it is five goal-costing errors in six matches as his alarming run of form continues.
Afterwards Mousinho criticised the defending in front of the goalkeeper, with Madiodio Dia the centre-half culprit for twice not getting close to Dalby, while Zak Swanson wasn’t quick enough to Conway to prevent the cross.
Still, it served as the leveller and stirred Bolton into action, who should have gone on to lead at the break, such was their subsequent superiority over the Blues.
Improved second half
Pompey were better in the second half, although Murphy departed after 65 minutes as they looked to ease the returning winger back into the first-team, replaced by Ryan Kavuma-McQueen on the left.
Regardless, Pompey never suggested they were capable of finding a winner and instead it was the Trotters who finished the stronger and far more likely to find a way.
It represented a frustrating afternoon for Mousinho’s men, with Tyrese Shade persistently caught offside, Kamara again underwhelming, this time in a number 10 role, and Jayden Meghoma limping off in stoppage time with an ankle injury.
Yet Murphy was back starting and among the goals - and the outlook is considerably more encouraging than the past.
